2 DAYS AGO • 4 MIN READ

Why Amazon Loses Billions on Shipping on Purpose

profile

Read Startup

Read Startup is an in-depth startup case study newsletter that helps students, young professionals, new founders, and curious business readers understand how real companies grow, win, fail, and make strategic decisions.

15 November

Why Amazon Loses Billions on Shipping on Purpose

Hey Startup enthusiasts,

This this is Read Startup. Today we're breaking down a loss so big it looks like a mistake, except it was the plan all along. Amazon spends more to ship your Prime orders than it charges you for shipping, by billions of dollars a year. That gap is not a leak in the business. It is the business, and understanding why rewires how you think about pricing.

Let's get into it.

A loss the size of a small country's budget

Start with the number that makes finance people wince. In 2016, Amazon collected $8.9 billion in shipping fees and spent $16.2 billion getting orders to doorsteps. That is a net shipping loss of about $7.2 billion in a single year.

It was not a one-off. The loss had climbed from around $5 billion the year before, and it kept growing as Amazon shipped more items for free, faster. Any normal company would treat a line like that as an emergency. Amazon treated it as an investment and pressed harder on the gas.

Why Amazon wants that loss to grow

To see the logic, stop looking at shipping as a product and start looking at it as bait.

Free two-day shipping is the headline benefit of Prime, the $99-a-year membership. The free shipping is not meant to make money on its own. It is meant to make you a Prime member, and once you are a Prime member, your behavior changes. You stop comparison shopping. You buy the batteries, the dog food, and the phone charger on Amazon instead of anywhere else, because shipping already feels free and instant.

That is the flywheel. Cheap, fast shipping pulls people into Prime. Prime members buy more often and across more categories. More spending funds more warehouses and faster delivery, which makes Prime even more worth keeping. By 2016, more than 50 million itemswere eligible for free two-day shipping, up 73 percent in a year.

The shipping loss buys a habit

Every free delivery is Amazon paying to turn an occasional shopper into a default one. The company is not pricing a single transaction to break even. It is spending to own the next few years of that customer's orders. Seen that way, a $7.2 billion shipping loss is one of the cheapest customer-retention programs ever run, because it buys a habit that is very hard to break.

Who actually pays for your free shipping

A loss leader only works if something else is strong enough to carry it, and this is where Amazon's structure matters.

In 2016, Amazon posted an overall profit of $2.4 billion, up from $596 million the year before. That profit did not come from retail. It came mostly from Amazon Web Services, the cloud division, which brought in $12.2 billion in sales and more than $3.1 billion in operating profit, the bulk of Amazon's total. In plain terms, the cloud business quietly paid for the shipping bleed in the shopping business. The free-shipping engine had a separate engine funding it.

The moat competitors could not copy

Rivals underestimated one more thing. By eating shipping costs year after year, Amazon trained customers to expect free delivery as the default, which made it painful for smaller retailers to compete. Once "free shipping" becomes the baseline shoppers assume, a competitor without Amazon's scale or a cash-rich side business cannot match it without bleeding out.

So the loss did double duty. It locked in Amazon's own customers through Prime, and it raised the cost of competing for everyone else. Amazon also poured money into its own delivery network, from cargo planes to local trucks, so that over time it could shrink the very shipping costs it was choosing to absorb.

The pricing idea worth stealing

The move underneath all of it is simple to say and hard to do: price for lifetime value, not for the margin on a single sale. A Prime membership that loses money per shipment can still be wildly profitable once you count everything that member buys over the years. Amazon was willing to lose on the order to win the customer.

Founder takeaways

Amazon's shipping loss is a masterclass in spending now to earn later. Four ideas to carry into your own pricing:

Separate the hook from the money-maker. Prime's free shipping is the hook; the profit comes from everything a locked-in member buys afterward. Decide which part of your product is bait meant to pull people in and which part actually earns, and stop demanding that the bait turn a profit on its own.

Price for lifetime value, not the single transaction. Amazon loses on each shipment and wins on the customer's decade of orders. Work out what a loyal customer is worth over their whole relationship with you, then decide how much you can afford to lose up front to win them.

Make sure something funds the loss leader. The shipping bleed only worked because AWS was printing profit alongside it. If you plan to lose money on one part of the business to build a habit, be clear-eyed about which healthy engine is paying for it. A loss leader with nothing behind it is just a loss.

Use a loss to build a moat, not just sales. Amazon's free shipping did not only win orders, it reset what customers expect and made everyone else's economics harder. When you spend to acquire, ask whether that spend also raises the barrier for the next competitor, because the best money buys both a customer and a moat.

Feedback

​Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you have specific feedback or anything interesting you’d like to share, please let us know by replying to this email.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Read Startup

Read Startup is an in-depth startup case study newsletter that helps students, young professionals, new founders, and curious business readers understand how real companies grow, win, fail, and make strategic decisions.